Civil Demand Letter for Shoplifting: An Overview of Retail Loss Recovery Processes and Your Defense

shows a civil demand letter for shoplifting

What is a Civil Demand Letter for Shoplifting?

When caught shoplifting, you face both criminal and civil penalties. The criminal charges are handled by local courthouses in Orange County, including Fullerton Courthouse, Santa Ana, Westminster, and Newport Courthouse. As for the civil demand letter, it arrives by mail. You will receive two pieces of mail: one from the attorney concerning the Civil Demand Letter for Shoplifting and another from the Orange County District Attorney’s Office. This article discusses the Civil Demand Letter for shoplifting. A Penal Code permits the victim to seek compensation in cases where you are convicted of shoplifting.

Civil Demand

Definition and Legal Basis for Civil Demand Letter for Shoplifting in the Context of Shoplifting:

Laws authorize merchants to recoup losses, hence the issuance of civil demand letters. However, merchants sometimes make excessive claims for the lost amount. In many shoplifting instances, the items are recovered, so there is no actual loss. Despite this, merchants may still send out demand letters for $500, a practice that is unfair and unrealistic.

Infographic 800x2000 px 15

Differences Between Civil Demand Letters and Criminal Charges:

Civil Demand Letter for Shoplifting and criminal charges are distinct. After a shoplifting incident, a criminal court case will be held at a local courthouse. However, civil demand letters are a civil matter and unrelated to criminal charges. It is a misconception that paying the civil demand letter will resolve criminal charges. I have seen clients who believed paying the civil demand would exempt them from court for their shoplifting Penal Code 484 charges, resulting in arrest warrants when they failed to appear.

The Process of Receiving a Civil Demand Letter:

The Civil Demand Letter for Shoplifting is not issued immediately after a shoplifting incident. It typically arrives two to three weeks later, often before your court date. The letter warns that failure to pay may lead to civil action. While they can pursue damages, proving a loss is challenging, especially when the merchant has recovered the stolen property.

Common Practices of Retailers and Their Legal Representatives:

Retailers commonly inform clients to expect a civil demand letter by mail. Legal representatives of these retailers may aggressively follow up if you contact them.

Potential Consequences of Ignoring a Civil Demand Letter:

Ignoring a civil demand letter can lead to civil court action. However, proving damages is difficult, particularly as most merchants recover their property after a shoplifting incident.

Discussing Legal and Financial Repercussions:

Not responding to the letter could result in a civil judgment and potential attorney fees. These are possible outcomes, not certainties.

When to Pay or Challenge the Demand:

Generally, I advise clients not to worry about the civil demand letter in shoplifting cases, as payment doesn’t affect the criminal case. However, in some instances, paying the demand could lead to dismissal or a civil compromise in the criminal case.

Role of a Criminal Defense Attorney:

A criminal defense theft attorney can manage the civil demand letter on your behalf, negotiate with the company, and provide guidance.

The Importance of Legal Representation:

Legal representation can prevent civil attorneys from pressuring you into paying unnecessary fees, especially if the stolen item has been recovered. Additionally, a defense attorney can help avoid a criminal conviction for a petty theft Penal Code 484 shoplifting charge.

How a Criminal Defense Attorney Can Assist with Civil Demand Letters:

A civil attorney experienced in shoplifting cases can effectively handle civil demand letters, even though they are non-criminal issues.

What exactly is a Civil Demand Letter and how is it related to shoplifting incidents?

A civil demand letter typically follows most shoplifting incidents. These letters are written by attorneys contracted by stores to collect money. However, they do not affect the criminal case, contrary to what many believe. Unfortunately, many people are under the impression that paying off the civil demand letter will resolve the criminal case. This is not true.

How do Civil Demand Letters differ from criminal charges in shoplifting cases?

Civil demand letters are different from criminal charges because they deal only with monetary issues. If you do not pay the civil demand letter, the only recourse for the plaintiff or the store is to take you to court for a monetary judgment. Unlike criminal charges, if you ignore them, you risk a bench warrant for your arrest, and there is a potential for being detained by police and taken into custody or jail.

What are the typical contents of a Civil Demand Letter, and what actions does it request from the recipient?

A typical civil demand letter from an attorney cites the Penal Code and the legal sections entitling them to relief. It usually includes a generic amount, often $250 or $500, to be paid to the store or the law firm representing the store.

Why do retailers send Civil Demand Letters, and are their claims always legitimate?

Retailers send civil demand letters primarily for monetary reasons. The claim in a civil demand letter is always legitimate. However, the amount requested often warrants scrutiny, especially in cases where the merchandise is recovered and the store suffers no loss. The questionable part is the derivation of the $500 amount, which is a common issue with civil demand letters.

What are the potential consequences of ignoring a Civil Demand Letter?

Ignoring a civil demand letter could lead to the store or their attorney filing a case against you in civil court. This puts you at risk of monetary damages and possibly attorney fees.

In what situations should one consider paying the demand in the Civil Demand Letter, and when is it advisable to challenge it?

In my opinion, it’s generally advisable to challenge a civil demand letter. However, there are exceptions when you might consider paying the demand. These include situations where payment can be tied to a civil compromise with the Criminal Court. This is complex and should only be handled by an attorney familiar with the judge and prosecutor, as they can gauge the likely outcome of paying off the civil demand letter under the Civil Compromise Code.

How can a criminal defense attorney assist with a Civil Demand Letter in a shoplifting case?

A defense attorney can help with a civil demand letter by reaching out and expressing your disinterest in paying. They can also designate themselves as your representative in case a lawsuit is filed. Knowing that you have an attorney often deters firms from pursuing further action, as they prefer not to engage with represented individuals.

What are the legal and financial repercussions of not responding to a Civil Demand Letter?

The legal and financial repercussions of not responding to a civil demand letter include the risk of a civil lawsuit. If a case is filed against you in civil court, you must disclose it on applications for licenses, job applications, and other relevant documents. Financially, you could be liable for several hundred dollars and potentially attorney fees.

Let’s Talk About You

Let’s Talk About You Fight Your case and get Representation in Court.

Read our Reviews


Hand down the best attorney I have ever worked with!!! My friend recommended Hieu because I needed to expunge something I did when I was young and dumb. Hieu is very humble, personable, and made me feel very comfortable. He's surprisingly funny too. Something not all lawyers are / can do. His pricing is very reasonable and he updated me on everything frequently. I highly recommend him!!!!

Lila K

I had interviewed many attorneys to discuss my very unfortunate situation that was set by someone I knew. Hieu Vu was the most honest, caring, and professional attorney with compassion and empathy I ever interviewed. HE REALLY HAD A HEART. His fees were very reasonable and he will fight for you not just for your dollars but because he cares for his clients... I would strongly recommend him if you feel your life is upside down. Things happen but we learn to become better person.

Mark K

Tell Your side of the Story

There's always more to one side of a story. It's important that your site gets heard.

Other Post

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest