Caught Shoplifting at Costco? Navigating the Consequences and Legal Defense

shows the picture of Costco in Tustin at the Market Place

Three Key Points from the Article:

  1. Costco has advanced loss prevention techniques, resulting in fewer shoplifting occurrences relative to other retailers. Their strategies include controlling entrances/exits and providing a membership format.
  2. If caught shoplifting at Costco, individuals face immediate action from security, potential police involvement, and classification of their act as a misdemeanor or felony based on evidence and intent.
  3. Being convicted of shoplifting at Costco carries significant legal and personal consequences, including potential jail time, civil penalties, and damage to one’s reputation and employment prospects. However, there are legal avenues available for defense, and not all actions, such as paying a civil demand letter, are immediately advisable.

Shoplifting Charges? Costco Theft Explained

In an era where retail theft is steadily rising, giants like Costco have implemented groundbreaking tactics to curb shoplifting. As the shopping carts grow larger, so do the company’s efforts to protect their inventory. If you’ve ever wondered what happens behind those vast warehouse walls when someone attempts to outsmart the system, this is your exclusive insight into the world of “Caught Shoplifting at Costco.”

Infographic 800x2000 px 17

Being Caught Shoplifting at Costco is not a proud moment. Costco is one of the most successful companies when it comes to stopping shoplifting. Their shrinkage of inventory numbers is below others in the industry. This term refers to occurrences of shoplifting to merchandise for sale. It is a standard used in the retail theft industry to measure the effectiveness of loss prevention officers.  A Recent business article by Business Insider explains how Costco does this. 

sholifting at costco 1

Costco Loss Prevention and What they Do to Catch Shoplifters.

“By strictly controlling the entrances and exits and using a membership format, we believe our inventory losses — shrinkage — are well below those of typical retail operations,” the report reads. Costco is also known to pay higher wages than Walmart and Target, thereby increasing worker satisfaction and reducing the amount of theft on the part of employees”
sholifting at costco 2

What happens when you get caught shoplifting at Costco?

Shoplifting is a problem that most big stores deal with on a daily basis. When Caught Shoplifting at Costco, you will immediately be escorted into the back of the store by security guards who will then call the police. The security personnel in the retail industry are not nice to shoplifters. Loss prevention officers will often be very hostile to people who are suspected of shoplifting.

Police Officer Will Arrive and Decide If it is a Misdemeanor or Felony. 

Often times they will let you sit there after being Caught Shoplifting at Costco for hours until an officer on duty has to the time drop by and take a report. In most cases, police officers are angels compared with loss prevention officers.  The officer will review the report by the loss prevention officers and categorize the forms of theft and your method. This goes into whether you used instruments or if you had the intent to steal when you walked into the store or whether this is a form of employee theft.  After this, the officer will decide whether your case is a felony theft or misdemeanor theft . 

Consequences if you get Caught Shoplifting at Costco

If you have been charged with shoplifting at Costco, you are probably facing jail time and hefty fines. You may also have to deal with the embarrassment of the whole thing becoming public knowledge. Aside from the criminal record on your permanent record. A theft conviction is one of the most problematic charges when it comes to potential employers making decisions about hiring. It is hard to bring someone on who steals. 

sholifting at costco 3

Being Convicted for Shoplifting at Costco is a Crime of dishonesty. 

For misdemeanor crimes it is most likely you will 0 days in jail for stealing or any kind of significant jail sentence. However, if the amount goes over a specific amount then the jail sentence can be significant. In addition to the jail sentence, you are also facing a civil penalty in the form of a civil demand letter. 

What to do When You Get Caught Shoplifting at Costco

You may think that being caught shoplifting is the end of the world however, there are some steps you can to take to resolve the situation. We will discuss the legal process in the next paragraphs.

Hiring Your Lawyer

But, you still have options. First, you need to hire a criminal defense attorney who is experienced in shoplifting cases. Second, you need to make sure that your lawyer knows everything that happened and can explain it to the prosecutor. This is your chance to tell your side of the story. You will need your attorney to review your case and any videos that came with the case.

Do Not Pay the Civil Demand Letter For Shoplifting.

You should not immediately pay the store. Paying the letter does not make your problem go away with the court unless you agree it is for the purpose of a civil compromise. If you are able to pay it and have them accept the payment as a civil compromise then your case can be dimissed.

shows the picture of a civil demand letter given to shoplifters
Civil demand letters are given to shoplifters after they are caught

How does Costco’s loss prevention strategy differ from other major retailers?

Costco’s loss prevention strategy is unique compared to other major retailers because it operates as a membership-based store. They monitor who enters and exits the store, and they also station personnel outside to check receipts. These employees count items and ensure they match the receipt. Additionally, Costco has surveillance cameras that monitor for any suspicious activities, such as customers hiding items in their bags or leaving merchandise under carts. These combined efforts define Costco’s loss prevention strategy.

What does being “escorted to the back of the store” mean after getting caught shoplifting at Costco?

After being escorted to the back of the store, suspected shoplifters are questioned about the items they have. A loss prevention officer will pose specific questions to ascertain if theft has occurred. Their approach might be direct and to the point. Along with the interrogation, a trespass notice is issued, meaning the individual cannot return to the store. Furthermore, the loss prevention officer will confiscate the individual’s Costco membership, preventing them from shopping there in the future.

How do loss prevention officers determine if someone intends to steal?

Loss prevention officers are skilled at their jobs, having encountered many instances of theft. They are trained to recognize suspicious body language and behaviors. Moreover, they observe how customers handle merchandise, either directly on the floor or via surveillance cameras. Often dressed in plain clothes, they blend in with regular shoppers. Their observations combined with a person’s actions can lead them to deduce intent, especially if someone attempts to leave without paying.

What’s the difference between felony theft and misdemeanor theft in a shoplifting scenario?

The primary distinction between felony theft and misdemeanor theft is a threshold of $950.

How severe can the penalties be if convicted of shoplifting at Costco?

Penalties for shoplifting at Costco can range from a misdemeanor to a felony. There are no infractions for shoplifting at this store. A misdemeanor can result in up to one year in jail, while felonies carry heavier penalties. However, these are the maximum sentences and may not reflect typical outcomes, especially if an individual complies with probation terms.

How does a shoplifting conviction impact my permanent record?

A shoplifting conviction will leave a mark on your permanent record. When applying for jobs or state licenses where you’re asked about criminal convictions, this will need to be disclosed. Such a record can be particularly significant for professions like accounting where trustworthiness is paramount.

If caught, should I immediately admit to my actions or wait to speak with a lawyer?

If caught shoplifting at Costco, it’s best not to make any statements. Inform them that you wish to speak with an attorney. When police arrive, only provide basic identification information. While it may feel uncomfortable, your silence cannot be used against you in court, nor can your request for legal representation.

What is the significance of a civil demand letter, and should I pay it?

A civil demand letter seeks compensation for civil penalties associated with shoplifting. Laws allow businesses to recoup losses from theft. However, some companies may exploit this, issuing letters even without verifiable losses. Non-payment can affect your credit, but there are procedures a company must follow to collect. Whether you should pay depends on various factors, including your goals. If you’re hoping a criminal case will be dropped by paying, understand that the two matters are separate.

How can a criminal defense attorney help if I’m caught shoplifting?

A criminal defense attorney can obtain and review the police report, videos, and audio recordings related to your case. They can represent you in court, negotiating with the prosecution. Given their knowledge of local laws, judges, and prosecutors, they can guide your case towards a favorable outcome.

How important is it for my lawyer to see any videos or reports related to my case?

Reviewing all evidence, including videos and reports, is crucial in any criminal case. This ensures an informed approach when seeking a resolution.

Can a shoplifting charge at Costco be dropped or reduced with the right legal approach?

Yes, with the appropriate legal strategy, a shoplifting charge at Costco can be reduced or even dropped. Understanding court dynamics and the legal landscape can greatly influence the outcome, potentially preventing a criminal conviction.

Shoplifting at Costco, or any retail store for that matter, carries repercussions that go beyond a mere legal charge. It affects one’s credibility, employment prospects, and emotional well-being. However, in the labyrinth of laws, there remains a glimmer of hope. With the right defense strategy, understanding the process, and learning from past mistakes, one can navigate their way back to a second chance.

Let’s Talk About You

Let’s Talk About You Fight Your case and get Representation in Court.

Read our Reviews


Hand down the best attorney I have ever worked with!!! My friend recommended Hieu because I needed to expunge something I did when I was young and dumb. Hieu is very humble, personable, and made me feel very comfortable. He's surprisingly funny too. Something not all lawyers are / can do. His pricing is very reasonable and he updated me on everything frequently. I highly recommend him!!!!

Lila K

I had interviewed many attorneys to discuss my very unfortunate situation that was set by someone I knew. Hieu Vu was the most honest, caring, and professional attorney with compassion and empathy I ever interviewed. HE REALLY HAD A HEART. His fees were very reasonable and he will fight for you not just for your dollars but because he cares for his clients... I would strongly recommend him if you feel your life is upside down. Things happen but we learn to become better person.

Mark K

Tell Your side of the Story

There's always more to one side of a story. It's important that your site gets heard.

Other Post

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest